Can a soundbar get a 5.1.2-channel billing with out separate encompass audio system? That’s the query LG’s SP9YA poses, which comes labeled as a 5.1.2 soundbar regardless of missing a pair of wi-fi encompass modules; as an alternative, the soundbar delivers its encompass cues with side-firing drivers in the principle speaker itself. The SP9YA isn’t the primary soundbar to aim this trick; the Artistic SXFI Service tries one thing comparable, and with equally combined outcomes. (LG does provide an non-obligatory rear speaker package for 7.1.2 audio.)
However whereas the SP9YA’s standing as a real 5.1.2 soundbar is debatable, its strong, full-bodied sound and vigorous Dolby Atmos and DTS:X top results are in little doubt, even when its encompass cues aren’t as distinct as they could possibly be. The SP9YA additionally packs an array of spectacular options, together with AI-powered room correction, eARC, built-in AirPlay 2 and Chromecast, in addition to assist for Alexa speaker teams and Spotify Join.
This evaluate is a part of TechHive’s protection of the perfect soundbars. Click on that hyperlink to learn critiques of competing merchandise, together with a purchaser’s information to the options it’s best to take into account when buying.
Specs
LG payments the SP9YA as a 5.1.2-channel soundbar, so it’s somewhat complicated once you open the field to seek out solely the principle soundbar unit and the wi-fi subwoofer, however no wi-fi encompass audio system. As I discussed earlier, LG counts the SP9YA’s pair of side-firing drivers as encompass channels, making it a 5.1.2 soundbar relatively than a 3.1.2 configuration. As we’ll see (and listen to) later, these drivers on the facet of the soundbar can’t fairly compete with separate encompass audio system. Happily, you possibly can improve the SP9YA utilizing LG’s $180 SPK8-S Wi-fi Rear Speaker Package for a full-on 7.1.2 setup, however LG didn’t provide us with the package for this evaluate.
In any occasion, the SP9YA incorporates a whole of 11 drivers, together with 10 in the principle soundbar unit. The left, proper, and middle channels every get their very own oval-shaped woofers (40x100mm) and tweeters (additionally 40x100mm), that are flanked by round 2.5-inch facet woofers that offer audio for the 2 encompass channels. On prime of the soundbar housing are two up-firing 2.5-inch drivers that ship top cues for Dolby Atmos and DTS:X soundtracks. Lastly, the wi-fi subwoofer has a 7-inch driver.
Ben Patterson/IDGThe LG SP9YA delivers its encompass results by way of side-firing drivers relatively than bodily encompass audio system.
The upfiring drivers provide Dolby Atmos and DTS:X top cues by bouncing hold forth your ceiling, a neater and extra inexpensive various to top audio system which are truly put in in your ceiling. However whereas upfiring drivers are a typical function of Dolby Atmos and DTS:X-supporting soundbars, they require a sure sort of ceiling to operate correctly—specifically, a flat, sound-reflecting ceiling that’s between 7 and 14.5 ft in top. You probably have ceiling beams or a vaulted ceiling, upfiring drivers for Atmos or DTS:X gained’t reduce it; in these instances, you could be higher off with a soundbar that employs virtualization for top cues.
Measuring 48 x 2.2 x 5.7 inches (WxHxD), the 13.9-pound SP9YA is sort of huge, stretching your entire size of the media cupboard that holds my 55-inch LG C9 OLED TV. That mentioned, the soundbar additionally has a reasonably low profile, permitting it to take a seat under my low-slung set whereas barely grazing the underside fringe of the display.
In the meantime, the 8.7 x 15.4 x 12.3-inch, 13.9-pound subwoofer is mid-sized so far as wi-fi subs go, which is to say that it’s not one thing you can (or would wish to) tuck discretely subsequent to your couch. As a substitute, it’s higher off someplace behind your TV, ideally not too near a wall.
Apart from inserting the SP9YA in entrance of a TV, you can additionally mount it on a wall beneath your TV, and happily, LG gives each a mounting template and wall brackets for that very goal.
Talking of what’s included, LG provides an optical cable however—as with earlier soundbars—no HDMI cable. After all, you possibly can snag an honest HDMI cable for lower than $10, however nonetheless, that’s somewhat stingy, LG.
Inputs and outputs
The SP9YA’s varied ports sit in a proper rear cavity, and also you get simply 4 of them: an HDMI enter, an HDMI output that helps HDMI-ARC/eARC, an optical (Toslink) enter, and a USB-A port that may entry audio recordsdata.
The soundbar’s two HDMI connectors offer you a few choices by way of connecting to a TV. First, you can plug a video supply straight into the SP9YA’s HDMI enter after which ship each video and audio from the soundbar’s HDMI output (4K HDR passthrough is supported, together with Dolby Imaginative and prescient) to considered one of your TV’s HDMI inputs. Since there’s just one HDMI enter, nevertheless, you’d be restricted to connecting solely a single video supply to the SP9YA. Frankly, given the SP9YA’s lofty price ticket, we’d have favored to see not less than one further HDMI enter.
Ben Patterson/IDGThe LG SP9YA comes with an HDMI enter, an HDMI output that additionally helps HDMI-ARC and eARC, an optical enter, and a USB port that may entry a wide range of audio file codecs, together with FLAC recordsdata.
The opposite choice is to attach your video sources to your TV’s HDMI inputs, after which ship audio all the way down to the soundbar’s HDMI-ARC port. Doing so means you’ll be capable of join as many video sources as your TV’s HDMI inputs will permit, and also you’ll additionally be capable of hear audio out of your TV’s built-in streaming apps by way of the soundbar. Even higher, the SP9YA helps eARC, an “enhanced” model of ARC that enables for lossless Dolby TrueHD and DTS-HD Grasp Audio tracks, which usually grace Blu-ray discs. (You may learn extra about ARC and eARC right here.)
Apart from the HDMI connectors, there’s additionally the optical enter for connecting an older, HDMI-less TV. There are not any RCA inputs for TVs that don’t even have optical outputs, however let’s face it; in case you’re coughing up $1,000 for a soundbar, you’re most likely not going to hook it as much as a tube TV from the 90s (and even earlier) anyway.
Lastly, the USB-A port can play WAV, MP3, OGG, AAC, and FLAC recordsdata, together with as much as 24-bit FLACs with 192kHz sampling charges. I linked a USB flash drive with a 24-bit/96kHz FLAC file and managed to play it with none points. (I’ll focus on the way it sounded in a bit.)
Setup
When you’ve both positioned the soundbar in entrance of your TV or put in it beneath your TV, you plug it into an influence socket utilizing a roughly 5-foot captive twine, which terminates in (fortunately) a typical two-prong plug relatively than a wall wart. The wi-fi subwoofer comes pre-paired with the soundbar, and it ought to join routinely as soon as plugged in. If it doesn’t, you possibly can manually pair the soundbar and the sub, however the automated pairing course of labored seamlessly for me.
Whereas LG soundbars with built-in Google Assistant use the Google Residence app to hook up with your Wi-Fi community, the SP9YA (which lacks built-in Google Assistant—extra on that in a bit) makes the reference to the brand new LG Sound Bar app, and the method was flawless. After firing it up on my iPhone and granting it permission to make use of Bluetooth, the app shortly discovered the SP9YA and prompted me to decide on my community SSID and enter my password. Lower than a minute later, the connection was made, and the soundbar immediate confirmed up as an choice amongst my different AirPlay 2 and Chromecast units.
Apart from the Wi-Fi setup, the SP9YA provides a room calibration function, which detects the acoustics of your room by bouncing sounds off your partitions and furnishings. Not like the Sonos Arc, which employs the microphone of an iPhone to carry out its measurements, the SP9YA makes use of its personal built-in microphone to take its calibration readings. The entire course of takes just a few minutes, and you may evaluate the outcomes with the sound of the uncalibrated soundbar. Whereas LG’s AI Room Calibration course of isn’t as exact as extra superior calibration programs akin to Audyssey (which takes readings from eight microphone positions), it’s a welcome function given the SP9YA’s worth level.
Controls, distant, and app
The SP9YA has seven capacitive contact buttons that sit on prime of the principle soundbar unit: energy, enter choose—which, fortunately, is now not labeled “F” (for “Perform”) because it was in earlier fashions—quantity up and down, play/pause, Bluetooth pair, and Wi-Fi.
Ben Patterson/IDGThe LG SP9YA’s distant has a modern, ergonomic design, nevertheless it’s a disgrace the quantity buttons are so excessive up on the wand.
The soundbar’s two-microphone array is straight in entrance of the highest buttons (though the 2 small mic holes are so small that they’re simple to overlook), whereas a five-digit show that dims after a brief interval of inactivity is on the entrance panel.
LG has redesigned the remotes for its 2021 soundbar line, and the ensuing wands are far sleeker than their boxy, cheap-looking predecessors. However whereas the distant that ships with the SP9YA is extra ergonomic than earlier LG soundbar remotes I’ve tried, the buttons are specified by such a manner that you could stretch your thumb out to succeed in the all-important quantity and mute buttons. The four-way navigation pad is inside simple attain, as are the sound mode, information, settings, and speaker stage buttons, nevertheless it appears odd that the quantity management sits so excessive up on the distant—and on the left-hand facet at that.
The brand new LG Sound Bar app is a step up from the getting old LG Wi-Fi Speaker app, and it permits you to management all of the capabilities of the soundbar, from altering inputs and adjusting the quantity to biking by way of the sound modes and trimming the speaker ranges. It should additionally immediate you to carry out the AI-powered room calibration course of at setup (you possibly can at all times re-run it everytime you want), in addition to tinker with the AV synchronization in case you run into any lip-sync points.
Audio casting and good residence integration
Whereas some LG soundbars include Google Assistant built-in, the SP9YA isn’t considered one of them; as an alternative, it merely “works with” Alexa and Google Assistant. Meaning, amongst different issues, that you could management a number of the soundbar’s capabilities with voice instructions, akin to “Alexa, flip LG soundbar quantity down,” or “Hey Google, skip monitor,” however you possibly can’t chat with Google Assistant or Alexa straight by way of the soundbar.
That’s the unhealthy information. The excellent news is that the SP9YA’s is blessed with a formidable array of casting and multi-room audio capabilities. Provided that, I gained’t complain an excessive amount of in regards to the lack of a built-in voice assistant.
Beginning with Alexa, you possibly can designate the SP9YA as a “most popular” speaker for considered one of your rooms or for your entire residence, which means that Alexa can routinely play tunes on the soundbar once you ask her to play music. You too can add the soundbar to an Alexa speaker group, akin to “Dwelling Room” or “Upstairs.”
Favor Chromecast? The SP9YA has you lined with built-in Chromecast assist, which implies you possibly can forged music to the soundbar from any Chromecast-enabled app or service, and you may as well add the soundbar to a Chromecast speaker group. Whenever you’re casting to the SP9YA by way of Chromecast, you possibly can ask Google Assistant to lift or decrease the quantity, skip tracks, or play or pause the music.
Even higher, the SP9YA additionally works with AirPlay 2, permitting you to forged audio to the soundbar from an iMac, iPhone, iPad, or one other Apple gadget, and much like Alexa and Chromecast, you possibly can add the soundbar to AirPlay speaker teams. Lastly, the SP9YA helps Spotify Join casting, too.
Sound modes and efficiency
The SP9YA options eight sound modes, together with Cinema (which upmixes all audio sources to five.1.2, together with 2.0 stereo audio), Music (which makes use of Meridian expertise to optimize its audio efficiency), Bass Blast (with ups the bass whereas additionally upmixing all sources to five.1.2), Clear Voice (for reinforcing dialogue), Normal (which delivers the audio with none upmixing and minimal tweaking), Sports activities, and Sport. There’s additionally an eighth mode, AI Sound Professional, which makes use of synthetic intelligence to customise the sound relying on what you’re listening to.
Whereas there are (clearly) loads of audio modes to select from, you can’t choose a mode in any respect with regards to Dolby Atmos or DTS:X content material.
I began my listening tour with the UHD Blu-ray of Star Wars: The Empire Strikes Again, specializing in the Battle of Hoth sequence in addition to the Asteroid Chase chapter. Initially, I observed that the SP9YA delivered a number of the finest Dolby Atmos top cues I’ve heard from a soundbar. Take the second when Luke tosses a grenade into an Imperial Walker, then drops to the bottom and watches the cascading explosions above. With the SP9YA, I may hear the sequence of muffled bursts with a precision that I hardly ever hear from soundbars with upfiring drivers. The identical goes for the sound of the chunks of falling ice from the ceiling as Vader and his troopers enter the crumbling Insurgent base.
Apart from its dealing with of top cues in Empire, I additionally appreciated how the SP9YA (like a number of the earlier LG soundbars I’ve heard) doesn’t emphasize high- and low-end sound on the expense of the mid-range; certainly, those that choose a brighter signature from a soundbar (like what you’ll hear from the Sonos Arc) may not just like the flatter sound of the SP9YA. And whereas the soundbar’s low-frequency results sounded somewhat boomy at first (notably the roar of the Millennium Falcon’s engine because it corkscrewed away from pursuing TIE Fighters), dialing the subwoofer stage down tamed the bass.
Shifting on to the UHD of Blade Runner (which, like Empire, has a Dolby Atmos soundtrack), I loved the distinct plops of rain as Deckard jogged for shelter beneath the awning of the noodle bar, in addition to the swooshing spinners above and under as Gaff delivered Deckard to police HQ. The UHD of Apollo 13 with its DTS:X sound impressed as effectively, with punchy bass, clear top results because the Saturn V’s engines roared to life, and a exact pop as Lovell jettisons the escape tower.
However whereas the SP9YA carried out properly by way of sound cues, its side-firing drivers delivered a extra muted response when it got here to encompass results. For instance, the pre-launch gurgle of the gasoline pumps in Apollo 13 didn’t really feel prefer it was coming from behind my couch, whereas the whine of the Insurgent speeders on Hoth in Empire by no means fairly appeared to swerve behind me. The facet drivers did handle to broaden the general soundstage and I did have a obscure sense of encompass atmospherics, however in order for you exact encompass cues from the SP9YA, you’ll have to crack open your pockets for the non-obligatory rear speaker bundle.
To attempt some non-Dolby Atmos and DTS:X content material, I spun up the usual Blu-ray of Titanic, which has a DTS-HD Grasp Audio soundtrack. Queuing up the “Ode to Titanic” chapter, I sampled the assorted sound modes; Cinema mode sounded huge however blown-out and hole (maybe resulting from aggressive upmixing of the peak channels), whereas additionally burying the dialog. To my ears, AI Sound Professional sounded far more pure and immersive, with Normal mode working a detailed second. With AI Sound Professional enabled, the pistons within the engine room sounded appropriately deep and kerplunky, whereas the hiss because the Titanic’s bow sliced by way of the water sounded crisp however not shrill, and it didn’t drown out Dawson’s “look look look!” as he identified the dolphins.
For music, I began by taking part in a 24-bit/96kHz FLAC of Chet Baker’s “Photo voltaic” by way of the USB port. Switching between the sound modes, I once more settled on AI Sound Professional (Music mode sounded wider however too boomy, whereas Normal mode was a tad higher however nonetheless shy of the AI mode), and I used to be impressed by the pop of the drums, the element of the brushes on the cymbals, and the positioning of the piano keystrokes. Properly achieved.
I additionally skipped round a number of extra tracks streamed by way of each Chromecast and AirPlay 2. I heard detailed, vigorous cymbal brushes from Bruce Springsteen’s “The Ghost of Tom Joad,” in addition to refreshingly clear keystrokes from Vlado Perlemuter’s efficiency of Ravel’s solo piano works (which frequently sound mushy on different soundbars). Lastly, the bass was good on Ciara’s “Stage Up,” punchy however not overbearing, whereas Ciara’s regular vocals had been breathy and natural relatively than detached (as they sound on different programs).
Backside line
So, is the LG SP9YA a real 5.1.2 soundbar? Technically sure, I suppose, though I doubt side-firing drivers will ever be an ideal substitute for bodily encompass audio system. Whereas the SP9YA’s encompass results aren’t as distinct as I’d like, its total sound is full, effectively rounded, and vigorous, all with out being too boomy or shrill.
Personally, I’d nonetheless advocate a 5.1.2 soundbar with precise encompass audio system, such because the Vizio Elevate (which, along with its wi-fi surrounds, options swiveling upfiring entrance drivers). However you probably have a lounge setup that’s not conducive to satellite tv for pc audio system, otherwise you’re prepared to cough up $180 for LG’s non-obligatory wi-fi rear speaker package, the SP9YA could be a super selection.
